Skip to main content

LIMITED TIME ONLY: Join for just $20/month on a 12-month Core+ plan!

​

Which nut or seed butter is the best for your nutrition goals?

Peanut butter isn’t the only game in town — here are the pros and cons to using almond butter, cashew butter, soy butter, or sunflower seed butter instead.

By Sarah Z. Wexler|Scientifically reviewed by Kelli Richardson, Ph.D., RDN
Last updated November 11, 2026

Peanut butter is a classic for a reason: It pairs perfectly with sliced banana for breakfast or as a snack, with jelly in a sandwich, and with chocolate for dessert. But PB isn’t the only popular nut butter, especially since allergies mean some schools and camps require kids to pack nut-free lunches and snacks. Now you may see a half-dozen different types of alternative nut and seed butters on grocery store shelves, including almond, cashew, soy, and sunflower seed butters. In addition to the classic of pairing a nut butter with sliced apple, add a spoonful to yogurt, oatmeal, smoothies; eat with crunchy vegetables like celery and carrots; or spread on toast, crackers, rice cakes, or pretzels.

“It’s worth exploring all your options because there are some notable differences in flavor, texture, and nutritional impact,” says Caitlyn Pote, M.S., R.D. LDN, nutrition program lead with Weight Watchers Clinic. Read on to find other differences and which nut or seed butter to try next.

Are nut butters healthy?

“Nut and seed butters can be a wonderful addition to someone's eating pattern, offering varying amounts of healthy fats, fiber, and protein,” Pote says. Nut butters in general are packed with heart-healthy nutrients and they’re often a way to add some protein to a meal or snack. That said, they have different nutritional values for each type of butter and brand, so the Weight Watchers Points® system can be a simple way to see what you’re getting.

“For example, for the same 2 tablespoon serving, peanut butter is on the higher end with approximately 6–7 points, depending on the brand, whereas soy butter or sunflower butter are around 5 points,” she says.

Peanut butter

Approximate, depending on brand, per 2 tbsp serving

Protein: 7g
Fiber: 2g
Points: 6

If allergy risks don’t demand that you avoid it, peanut butter is hard to beat because it’s a crowd-pleaser, more affordable, and available everywhere. It comes in dozens of varieties way beyond creamy or crunchy — some contain flavorings like cinnamon or chili powder and can pack nutritional boosts such as flaxseed, powdered egg whites, omega-3 and omega-6 fatty acids, says Pote. 

As always, we recommend reading labels before buying; some include added sugar as well, so you’ll generally want to look for ones that contain just two ingredients: peanuts and salt (and spices like cinnamon or chili if you'd like). For natural peanut butter where the oil separates, store the jar upside-down in your cabinet and you’ll find it easier to stir when you open it — and once it’s opened, keep it in the fridge to prevent re-separation. 

You may want to skip reduced fat peanut butter, as it often has added sugar to help improve its flavor when it’s missing fat, so it has a similar number of calories per serving as its full-fat cousin.

Almond butter

Approximate, depending on brand, per 2 tbsp serving

Protein: 7g
Fiber: 3g
Points: 5

Almond butter’s deep, subtle flavor makes for a grown-up AB&J sandwich. It’s also a nutritional powerhouse — depending on the brand and product. “Almond butter can have almost double the fiber as peanut butter,” Pote says. Plus, eating almonds is correlated with supporting healthy cholesterol levels already within a normal range and promoting cardiovascular well-being as part of a balanced diet. The only downside is that the consistency can feel a little gritty.

Cashew butter

Approximate, depending on brand, per 2 tbsp serving

Protein: 6g
Fiber: 1g
Points: 7

Cashew butter, which tastes exactly like the smile-shaped nuts it’s made from, is also an abundantly heart-healthy option. Its fat content is largely made up of oleic acid, which has been found to promote cardiovascular health — it’s the same healthy fat found in olive oil. “One consideration for cashew butter is that it can be slightly lower in protein than peanut butter,” Pote says.

Soy butter

Allergen Notice: Soy is a major food allergen recognized under the FDA FASTER Act. Do not consume if allergic to soybeans.

Approximate, depending on brand, per 2 tbsp serving

Protein: 7g
Fiber: 2g
Points: 6

If your child goes to a school or camp that bans nuts, you can still satisfy kids’ PB&J hankerings with soy nut butter, which technically isn’t a nut butter at all: It’s a spread made from roasted soybeans. (However, because soy is also classified as a major food allergen, it is not suitable for individuals with a soy allergy.) Since it’s the closest to peanut butter in terms of flavor, it’s the preferred option at most schools that have banned peanuts. Nutritionally, it’s typically lower in total and saturated fat than most nut butters, plus it offers a similar amount of fiber and protein per serving as PB. “It also usually has higher amounts of omega-3 fatty acids, making it a slightly more nutrient-dense PB alternative,” Pote says.

Sunflower seed butter

Approximate, depending on brand, per 2 tbsp serving

Protein: 6g
Fiber: 3g
Points: 6

Like soy butter, sunflower butter is free from peanuts and tree nuts; it’s made from sunflower seeds. Like cashew butter, it’s slightly higher in healthy fat, and it has a notably higher micronutrient composition (including vitamin E, iron, magnesium, and selenium) than PB. The only downside is it can be slightly lower in protein, depending on the brand. “But what it lacks in added protein, it makes up for in increased vitamins and minerals and its taste and texture are usually well-liked,” Pote says.

The bottom line

Peanut butter is a classic for a reason, but most grocery stores stock a wide range of other nut and seed butters, including almond butter, cashew butter, soy butter, and sunflower seed butter. With all of them, read the nutrition labels and ingredient lists to make a well-informed decision that meets your needs, such as to ensure you’re not getting more added sugar or sodium than you’re looking for, or to be aware of potential allergens. (Individuals with known food allergies should always inspect facility cross-contact statements on packaging before consuming.) Since each nut and seed butter has a unique flavor and texture, experiment with different types to find what works best for you.

Related Articles

This content is for general educational and information purposes. The content is not medical advice, does not diagnose any medical condition and is not a substitute for professional medical advice, diagnosis or treatment from a healthcare provider. Talk to your healthcare provider about any medical concerns.

Trust: You need this newsletter.

The field of weight management is evolving–and fast. New research. New treatments. Lots of misinformation. Our clinical newsletter helps sort it all out.